When the Plague Bags come out for our Seder, the toy frogs will have a place of honor at our table. We’ll call out the names of nine plagues instead of 10.
This isn’t the first time I’ve tinkered with Passover, but it’s the most sacrilegious thing I’ve done. Up until now, the changes I’ve made have been both spiritual and practical.
As an adult, I compiled my own Haggadah because I needed to find meaning in a holiday I didn’t observe as a child and had no frame of reference for, except bad food. During my service, we say a special prayer of thanks for the strong women in our lives, and we talk about the broken matzo representing unknown parts of ourselves. I serve lamb because I’ve never mastered brisket.
Why is this year is different from all other years? Because this year, I had cancer and survived — and in my struggle with disease, I developed a peculiar affection for the hopping balls of slime God sent to torment the Egyptians.
I haven’t always had a fondness for amphibians. But after a real plague entered my house, I think of frogs as nothing less than lifesavers. They helped me explain my diagnosis to my 9- and 14-year-old daughters. When I was feeling battered by chemotherapy, they reminded me that I was, in all likelihood, going to live.
As a parent, I’d already had difficult conversations with my children. We’d tackled divorce, the death of elderly relatives and loved ones stricken with progressive illnesses like multiple sclerosis and Alzheimer’s.
But last December, three weeks after my 46th birthday, I was the person who was very sick. A trip to the doctor for some moderate lower back pain yielded a much more ominous diagnosis: aggressive Stage 4 non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma.
I wasn’t really sure what I was going to say when I called the girls into my bedroom to explain what was happening.
“Mom has cancer, but it’s not the kind you die from,” were the first words that came out. Carolyn, 14, started to tear up; 9-year-old Lauren simply looked confused. Making a weak attempt at levity and trying to connect with them on their level, I then declared, “No one in this house is going to croak unless we get a frog.”
The next day, while I was at the oncologist, I asked the babysitter to take Lauren to Animal Alley at Toys ‘R Us to buy the largest stuffed one she could find. “Croakie” was in Lauren’s arms when they picked me up from my doctor’s appointment.
In our house, frogs became a symbol of hope. The news spread. During the four months I was undergoing chemotherapy, friends brought us all kinds of frog paraphernalia: pajamas, slippers, a robe, a picture frame. We got ones that sang, ones that danced and ones that made noise when you threw them on the floor, an action I periodically found very therapeutic.
My longtime boyfriend, who had already lost both his father and his best friend to cancer, gave me the tackiest collectible of all. It was a plastic, frog-head purse. A ring and a love letter were inside, reassuring me that we’d still get married and have the future together we’d been planning.
I have to admit, all the kitsch helped. My younger daughter would sit on my bed at night and perform little puppet shows with some of the frogs. All of this goofy stuff made me laugh, and, at times when I felt more like crying, they reminded me of the promise I’d made to my children and to myself.
“You croak. I don’t. That’s how this is going down,” I’d say to growing assortment of green junk on my dresser.
In April, I spent the first two nights of Passover on the lymphoma floor at Sloan Kettering receiving my final three-day infusion of chemotherapy. The first thing I did when I came home from the hospital was “de-frog” my bedroom.
As a well person, I collected “Gone with the Wind” movie memorabilia and vintage paper dolls. Disposing of the frogs was my way of declaring that I was well. But I couldn’t bring myself to throw them out, so I put them in shopping bags and stuck them in the basement, just in case I ever needed them again.
Even though I’ve been in remission since last April, I’ve decided to bring them out for our Seder. To my family, they are concrete symbols of the journey from the slavery of illness to the freedom of health.
Although I’m a textbook Scorpio, I now think of Passover as my birthday. For me, it will always signify the end of treatment and the beginning of recovery and my life as a cancer survivor. In case I haven’t messed with tradition enough, I’m also considering putting candles in my flourless chocolate cake, making a wish and blowing them out.
Cindy Hecht Suna is a writer living in Larchmont, N.Y.
A sense of humor, even during life's most challenging situations, really can be an effective coping tool. Your bravery and selflessness is truly an inspiration. Your children are very lucky to have such a wise and loving mother. You have given them an incredible gift. You are obviously a very special soul. Happy Birthday!
Cindy, I am a member of Larchmont Temple and I hope I meet you. Maybe Reva, who sent me your article, can introduce us. I had a tumor on my tongue last year and went through Pesach still in treatment. I was cured. This year I got prostate cancer and am starting the process all over again. It has been tough when I tell God that I have done my bit, how come again? But maybe it's meant to be. I know that I am looking for ways to live as egoless as possible so that I can be open to life, all people and to God and everything that he has created. I live in the present, notice everything around me, try not to ignore anything or anyone and in this way feel closer to the God I believe in who teaches me to love everything and to be a giving person as my reason for being. By giving love there is more love all around felt by everyone around me, even the toughies who eventually melt from compliments, courtesy and a smile. Sloan Kettering is one of the Temples most important to me. Everyone there has been so giving to me and I return it with all my heart. Thank you for your letter. With Fondness, Jed 914-833-0259
Dear Cindy, I don't have cancer, but I have recently had double coronary bypass surgery caused by generalized vascular disease, followed by a high blood pressure that the physicians can't get under control. So I know the jig is up, since they are convinced that I'm a ticking time bomb, ready to be hit with a stroke or heart attack at any moment. It focuses the mind wonderfully, I find. Of course, it's not as bad as cancer where you are in pain all the time. The killer in me lurks silent as a venomous snake, waiting for an opportune moment to strike, even possibly at this very moment. (I waited ... nothing happened ... whew, I'm safe now :) Well, what the hell, life had its worthwhile moments and, after all, I will be in good company. It's just my turn in the barrel; I always did wonder when it would come ...
Darling "Cinderela" So 'touched' by your creative thought. Your destination has been reached; being Cancer free! During your difficult journey, so many were at your side and others constantly had you in their thoughts. Love you Cindy darling. Uncle Bill
Cindy:YOur story was outstanding. It certainly showed the great strength and courage you have for yourself and yopur daughters.I had cancer 13 years ago and know the shock,fear,depression you had but more importantly the mindset to know that you will BEAT it.I know you have great family support because Joyce is the best at that. She is the sweetest,kindest,most empathetic person I know. Congradualtions on you publishing...Love Cousin Howie Boasberg
Cindy, Congratulations on three fronts! On being published, on surviving with style and great dignity, on being a better You! You faced a terrible and debilitating illness and You Won. What an inspiration you are to the rest of us. Enjoy the holiday with your girls, Lauren and Carolyn. May this be a truly peaceful and relaxing holiday for you and your family. Pesach Sameach! Your friend and neighbor, Monica.
Dear Cindy, I think I speak on behalf of our whole LT family when I say how proud and touched I am by this wonderful and inspiring story. You have truly taught others the meaning of liberation and the power of the journey from enslavement. May you continue to go from strength to strength, with gratitude for your wisdom and admiration for everything you continue to achieve, and wishing you and yours a sweet and happy Pesach! With much love, l'shalom, Andi
Cindy, You are another strong woman and life always has tests that we have to encounter. You have had your share and we hope that the rest of your life is a smooth road. Your sharing of your story which is so well written will now help others become stronger. Stay strong as you are a hero to all.
Cindy - the article is touching and inspirational, but your idea of empowering your kids and giving them a symbol with which to confront the cancer was brilliant. Many parents are fearful of talking to their children about cancer leaving them (the children) in a helpless position, but you were honest with them and also gave them a tool with which they could help their mom fight her cancer and which also served to comfort them and allowed them to laugh and have fun. As a social worker who works with people impacted with cancer, I have learned from you a way to help those whom I work with daily. Denise Raptoulis social worker Leukemia & Lymphoma Society
Cindy, Thank you for the inspiring story. I found your article searching on how to help children deal with illness. By chance did you grow up in Michigan? Thanks again for your thoughts.
Hey Glen, Yes, it's me. My e-mail address is chsuna2@aol.com. Nice to hear from you.
The Forward welcomes reader comments in order to promote thoughtful discussion on issues of importance to the Jewish community. In the interest of maintaining a civil forum, the Forward requires that all commenters be appropriately respectful toward our writers, other commenters and the subjects of the articles. Vigorous debate and reasoned critique are welcome; name-calling and personal invective are not. While we generally do not seek to edit or actively moderate comments, the Forward reserves the right to remove comments for any reason.