A Web site affiliated with the Presbyterian Church (USA) recently declared that “The Jewish community in the Diaspora must get a life.” It was wrong, and it was insulting, but I am more concerned about what lies behind the statement. There is a mindset even more wrong, and it is sadly growing among my fellow liberal Christians.
There are many definitions of life; none is fully acceptable or adequate. One is that life is what occupies our passions and demands our attention. The life we live is one where things matter to us. Life is in our passion, as opposed to our apathy. As opposed to lethargy, an inability to attend to much of anything, life leads us into a posture of attentiveness — seeing, hearing, thinking and giving ourselves over to that which demands our attention.
In this definition of life there are degrees of living; one is more or less passionate and more or less attentive. Dying is what happens on the lesser side of the equation. In dying it is very difficult to care, very hard to pay attention.
Liberal Christians are starting to come to life about the problems of Palestinians. We have been inattentive and dispassionate, even down right apathetic, for a good long time. Our apathy has made us complicit in lots of dying that has been going on.
We have come to life in stages. We learned that among Palestinians were fellow Christians, and this stirred our interest and we started to see and hear what we had failed to look at and listen to before. And our attitudes toward Muslims began to remind us of our lengthy and repugnant practice of antisemitism, and we began to pay more attention to all the Palestinian peoples — listening and caring and becoming increasingly passionate about their plight. In so many ways we can and should celebrate that this community of American Christians has come to life.
But passions can run dangerously hot, and I fear this is going on with many liberal Christians. Eager to come to life about the p light of Palestinians, which is a good thing, some among us have let our passion and compassion shift away from the plight of Israelis. We have let our long delayed solidarity with Jews start to slide away. And this is wrong.
Six decades ago some liberal Christians — way, way too few — directed their passion against the Nazi genocide and tried to stop the evil. In recent generations more and more liberal Christians have tried to come clean about the way our own religious life and practices have allowed abhorrent anti-Jewish beliefs and practices to persist. Liberal Christians have been coming to life about more just, more repentant, more life-affirming ways to be in community with Jews.
But it is difficult to pay attention to multiple things. It is hard to be passionate about much. It takes the fullness of life to do this.
At the heart of Christianity is the belief that God gives fullness of life. It is time for liberal Christians to attend to this belief. We need to keep passionate about the plight of Palestinians; we cannot become apathetic.
But we need to also be passionate about Israel and its deep worldwide meaning, especially for Jews. We cannot allow the coming to life we have begun in our solidarity with Jews to falter or fail.
Most of all, we need to understand that American Jews “have a life” about Israel — they care passionately, powerfully. In my experience, American Jews are full of life about the problems of Israel and the plight of Palestinians. In my experience, the ability of American Jews to pay attention to complicated and complex matters in the Middle East far exceeds that of all but a tiny minority of Christians.
If liberal Christians can balance and enlarge their passions and not burn out, we might just become one of the forces that bring fullness of life.
Reverend David Greenhaw, president of Eden Theological Seminary in St. Louis, is an ordained minister of the United Church of Christ.
Reverend Greenhaw is correct. The surge of sympathy for the Palestinians has overshadowed the real issue, which is the absolute right of Israel to exist as a sovereign democratic nation in a sea of hatred by its' Arab neighbors including the Palestinians. While the latter is more than entitled to their own self determination it should not be at Israel's expense. If Israels' adversaries claim that the Jewish people have exaggerated their claim to their land then history also shows that the Palestinians have more than done the same.
Bravo David Greenhaw!
DEAR REVEREND GREENHAW, I find many or most of us JEWS can hold 2 concepts at the same time, think in the grays, beautifully depicted in the movie "Fiddler on the Roof", when Tevya sings "on the other hand". It may be a consequence of Talmudic Scholars arguing over every bit of the Talmud. Just an opinion.
The Presbyterian church in America has never been partiticularly sympathetic to Israel or the establishment of a Jewish state in Palestine. I think that the present "problems" that the Presbyterian church bureaucracy has with Israel stem from the missionary work done by the church in the middle east in the ninteenth century and the churches general failure to address or deal with the real issues of poverty and medical needs in Palestine, Lebanon and Anatolia in the late ninteenth century. The churches involvement with Jordan in the early 1960's rather than attempting any sort of rapproachment with Israel after the 1967 war, I think, set the ground work for the present church's attitude towards Israel.
I couldn't agree more with what Reverend Greenhaw has written. What he has called for is a common sense approach that recognizes the undeniable suffering endured by the Palestinians while still recognizing the need to understand the American Jewish community and our relation to Israel. Given that the Reverend has taken such a balanced stand that recognizes the grievances of both sides, his words will most likely fall upon death ears on this very polarized issue.
Five Cheers for the pastor. Israel doesn't have a lot of world support. It has had much PR almost all bad. Israel doesn't seem to know how to get her side of the story to the public. But, this pastor writes well, thinks clearly and has an important message. Thanks.
There must be a great yawning vacancy in the minds and lives of those who go out of their way to dispense the gratuitous and offensive advice 'get a life' to others. Haven't they interests and passions of their own to focus upon, rather than the lives of others? Most people, and especially Jews, be they Israelis or part of the Diaspora, have been able to see the situation in the Middle East as it affects all peoples, and have done so, even when less than the best decisions have been made. We have asked that the Palestinias and their friends accept with us that the situation is multifaceted, and to join in discussion to come up with reasonable settlements for all parties. While it is nice that some people who did not pay much attention before suddenly noticed that there are some Christians among the Palestinians, and have decided, very late, to be part of the discussion on behalf of their coreligionists, they, too, have an obligation to work for the best solution. Their role is not to stand on the sidelines and cloud the effort to resolve with foolish pontifications of the 'get a life' variety to people who have a natural concern in the matter. "Fullness of Life" for all peoples is not a partisan or parochial issue. Thousands of years of common heritage and ultimately common interest must honored first for all lives to be fulfilled and comfortable.
The Forward welcomes reader comments in order to promote thoughtful discussion on issues of importance to the Jewish community. In the interest of maintaining a civil forum, the Forward requires that all commenters be appropriately respectful toward our writers, other commenters and the subjects of the articles. Vigorous debate and reasoned critique are welcome; name-calling and personal invective are not. While we generally do not seek to edit or actively moderate comments, the Forward reserves the right to remove comments for any reason.