For Jerusalem’s Sake
The letter sent last month by the Orthodox Union to Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert with regard to the possibility of his government ceding sections of Jerusalem to the Palestinian Authority was not, as your editorial asserts, motivated by “anger and insecurity” (“Holier Than Thou,” October 26).
Rather, it was a reflection of a policy resolution adopted, after sober consideration and debate, at the O.U.’s 2006 biennial convention. It was an appeal to Olmert to, in the words of the letter, not do “what would be unthinkable to the millions of Jews who, for centuries, could not come to Jerusalem, yet raised their voices with full conviction and deep longing” for Jerusalem. And our “assertiveness,” as you call it, is motivated by the belief that all Jews, throughout the world, have a share in the holy city.
In the weeks since we sent our letter, Palestinian leaders have continued to publicly state their denial of any Jewish connection to the Temple Mount and also expressed a desire to “control” not only the Temple Mount but the Western Wall as well. Such statements should alarm anyone who, while wishing for peace, also wishes for Israel to remain a Jewish state for the Jewish people, and we welcome everyone to join us in asserting ourselves for the sake of Jerusalem.
Nathan Diament
Director of Public Policy
Orthodox Union
Washington, D.C.
Empathy Beats Trauma
We agree with Leonard Fein’s statement that for the Jewish people, “yesterday’s trauma still overwhelms and tomorrow’s trauma is imminent” (“‘Israel Lobby’ Writers Miss the Real Jewish Conflict,” October 26). However, the thread that links all human beings regardless of race, religion, culture or gender is the suffering of trauma on some level or another. Fear and distrust are the common denominators of all people. What is lacking is the absence of empathetic application.
Arabs need to learn the history, atrocities and traumas the Jews have experienced and vice versa. Through empathy, tolerance and compassion we may come to the understanding that we all have more in common than we may think.
Odeh and Lena Aburdene
Washington, D.C.
Hans Jonas’s Genius
I was elated to see the review by David Kaufmann of Christian Wiese’s “The Life and Thought of Hans Jonas” (“One of Most Relevant Thinkers You’ve Never Heard Of,” October 19). Yes, Jonas’s writing, like much Germanic philosophy, could be turgid, dense and difficult, but when he soared, he reached heights of insight that could cover eons of human and earthly life. His “The Phenomenon of Life: Toward a Philosophical Biology” sums up millennia of human and non-human life, sets this development in a startling light and reintroduces respectability for the concept of teleology.
Jonas’s concern with the problem of how consciousness arose out of non-consciousness will give support to closet vitalists, and his 1984 book “The Imperative of Responsibility” pointed with almost eerie exactness at the problems of global warming and of technology over-reaching itself.
I hope this new publication reverses the trend of Jonas’s obscurity.
Roberta Kalechofsky
Marblehead, Mass.
Paternalism Lives
As an admirer of the Forward, I was shocked and offended by Paul Marx’s opinion article (“Create a ‘Bar Mitzvah’ for Black Boys,” October 19). The piece raised serious questions about the lingering effects of racist, paternalistic attitudes among the Jewish community.
It is naïve to assume that by transferring a Jewish custom to the African-American community, the complex problems of crime and drug abuse will be solved. Not only would such an idea be unsuccessful, but it is also deeply disrespectful to assert that our own traditions should be copied by the black community. Marx’s proposal for a “black boy” bar mitzvah would be laughable if it did not reflect the disturbing fact that many Americans, including the highly educated, do not consider blacks to be their intellectual or cultural equals. As Jews, we should be particularly sensitive to articles that denigrate others.
Joe Huennekens
Arlington, Va.
A God for Everyone
David Klinghoffer misses the nuance (“When Democrats Become Instruments of God,” October 19) when he decries the “muted reactions from Jews and other liberals” regarding the injection of religion into the Democrats’ presidential campaigns. The Democrats speak of God (acceptable to all religions). The Republicans speak of Jesus Christ. Ah, there’s the rub!
Gwen Weinberger
Aventura, Fla.
Compassion Deficit
I agree with the October 10 editorial “Bush and the Children.” I was genuinely shocked by the president’s lack of compassion when he vetoed a bipartisan bill that would extend medical insurance for poor children under the State Children’s Health Insurance Program.
Unlike many other countries, we have an abundance of medical resources available. With our resources comes a serious moral responsibility to make them available not only to poor children but to anyone who needs help. Our government must live up to this responsibility, and Congress must override the President’s veto of the SCHIP program.
**Nathan Weissler **
*Chevy Chase, Md. *
The Forward welcomes reader comments in order to promote thoughtful discussion on issues of importance to the Jewish community. In the interest of maintaining a civil forum, the Forward requires that all commenters be appropriately respectful toward our writers, other commenters and the subjects of the articles. Vigorous debate and reasoned critique are welcome; name-calling and personal invective are not. While we generally do not seek to edit or actively moderate comments, the Forward reserves the right to remove comments for any reason.
To post a comment, click to login:
Copyright © 2012, Forward Association, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
THIS IS A LETTER TO THE EDITOR. There is a situation that received wide coverage some many weeks ago, but which has now disappeared from the news media. It concerns the fact that many Holocaust survivors in Israel were destitute, and others were living with various levels of deprivation and stress. They had to protest on the streets..!! I was absolutely shocked to read about this, and have been waiting to learn that corrective measures were taken. So far nothing. Apparently, just another nine-day-wonder. This is appalling. I am writing to urge someone or some organization with the capability to act, do something to repair this situation. Holocaust survivors, especially those in the Holy Land, should be elevated to a place of honour. Their physical and all their medical needs should be taken care of. Gratis. Including their psychological and psychiatric needs. Where has our conscience gone. There should be widespread shame that this situation should have been allowed to exist. Here in North America, the richest and most powerful region of the world, there are many with the means of doing something about this painful shameful situation. Forget the politicians; for God's sake organize something, a trust or foundation with adequate resources. And begin right now. Otherwise surely we will be cursed. C. Alexander Brown, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.